Ruth Miller ‘s story
is told in hushed tones, with a distinct English accent typical of someone from Pennsylvania German. At sixty-two, she lives openly under her real name in a small Mennonite community, no longer hiding, but still carrying the weight of those years.
“Jacob was a good man,” he begins. “A good father, a good husband. He worked hard. He tried to do the right thing. But he made a mistake by borrowing from Charles Benton.”
Ruth explains that, at first, the loan seemed reasonable. Jacob needed equipment for his woodworking business: a new band saw, planers, tools that would allow him to go beyond basic furniture and create more elaborate pieces that would fetch better prices.
“We thought we could easily pay it back,” Ruth says. “Jacob’s work was popular. We received orders regularly. We had a plan.”
But when Jacob’s payment was delayed by a week in December 1991 —because a customer’s payment had also been delayed— Benton invoked the immediate refund clause.
“He came to our house,” Ruth recalls, her hands still trembling at the memory. “He said Jacob had breached the contract. He said we had to pay everything immediately. When Jacob said he couldn’t pay it all at once, Benton got angry. He said he would take the farm, the house. He said he would make sure we were left with nothing.”
The threats intensified in the following months. Benton’s visits became more frequent and aggressive. According to Ruth, he made veiled threats against the children, suggesting that Jacob’s failure to pay would have “consequences” for the family.
“He never said exactly what he was going to do,” Ruth explains. “But from the way he looked at the children, from the way he spoke… Jacob and I understood. He was threatening our children.”
In March 1992, after a particularly threatening encounter, Jacob made a decision. He would build a hiding place in the barn where the family could take refuge when Benton came, where they could hide until he left.
“Jacob worked at night,” Ruth says. “He converted that room in the back corner of the barn, soundproofed it with straw and cloth, and built the secret door. It took him three weeks. He told the children it was a game, that we were practicing hiding.”
The family began sleeping in the hidden room whenever they heard Benton’s truck approaching. They would quickly gather the essentials—blankets, food, water—and lock themselves inside until he left.
“It was terrifying,” Ruth says. “The children were crying. Little Mary didn’t understand why we had to be quiet, why we were hiding. David was having nightmares. But we were too scared to do anything else.”
By early summer, it became clear they couldn’t continue living like this. The children were showing signs of trauma. The farm was in disrepair, as they spent more time hiding than working. And Benton’s visits were becoming increasingly frequent.
“Jacob said we had to leave,” Ruth recalls. “I asked him how. We had no money, nowhere to go, and no way to escape without Benton finding us. That’s when Jacob went to see Benton for the last time.”
What Jacob negotiated with Benton remains unclear, as both men have since passed away. But based on Ruth’s account and the chronology of events, it appears Jacob reached an agreement: if Benton allowed them to leave Ohio peacefully, Jacob would give him the farm and consider the debt settled.
“Jacob wanted everything in writing,” Ruth says. “But Benton refused. He said Jacob’s signature on the deed of transfer was all he needed. If Jacob kept his end of the bargain—leaving Ohio and never coming back—Benton would keep his and wouldn’t sue them.”
The deal was done. On the night of July 13, 1992, the Miller family loaded what they could carry onto their wagon. They left everything else behind: the farm, the animals, most of their belongings, their entire lives.
“We left our breakfast that morning on the table,” Ruth says. “Jacob said it would look like we’d just left, like we were coming back. He didn’t want people to think we’d planned to leave. He wanted it to seem like a mystery.”
The plan was for the family to travel by carriage to a pre-arranged meeting point several miles away, where an Amish man from a neighboring district—someone who owed Jacob a favor—would transport them in a covered wagon to Indiana. From there, they would disappear into a new Amish community under assumed names.
“But when we left that night,” Ruth says, lowering her voice to almost a whisper, “Benton was there. He followed us in his truck to make sure we really left. He wanted to see us go.”
Margaret Stevens’ testimony confirmed this version: she had seen both Benton’s carriage and truck that night.
The family managed to contact their contact person, moved to a covered wagon, and began the journey to Indiana, which took several days. They arrived in Elkhart County in late July 1992, exhausted, traumatized, and grateful to be alive.
“We thought we would only stay for a year or two,” Ruth says. “We believed that after Benton forgot about us, we could go back home. But the years passed. The children grew up. We rebuilt our lives. And Jacob was afraid that if we went back, Benton would find us.”
So they stayed. Joseph and Rebecca Miller raised their children, worked hard, attended church, and never spoke of Ohio or their former life.
“The guilt was terrible,” Ruth says through tears. “We had abandoned our community, our church, our families. We had left with false pretenses, living under false names. Amish don’t do those things. We are honest people. But Jacob said it was better to be alive and ashamed than righteous and dead.”
When Jacob died in 2001, Ruth considered returning to Ohio and confessing everything. But by then, her children had rebuilt their lives in Indiana. Aaron was married with children. Sarah had joined a Mennonite church and was a teacher. David was an apprentice blacksmith. They had all overcome the trauma of their childhood, built fulfilling lives, and Ruth didn’t want to disrupt them.
“I thought I would take the secret to my grave,” she says. “I thought it was better that way. But when the detective came to my door and told me they had found the secret room, I knew God was telling me it was time to tell the truth.”
The reckoning
. Ruth’s testimony in 2013 solved Miller’s disappearance, but it raised new questions about justice and accountability.
Charles Benton had died in 2005, so it was impossible to file criminal charges. However, investigators reviewed his records and found evidence of similar patterns in other Amish families: predatory loans, threats, and forced abandonments.
“Benton operated for decades by preying on vulnerable people,” said Attorney General Eric Holder, who reviewed the case. “The Amish don’t use lawyers, file lawsuits, or involve law enforcement in community disputes. He took advantage of that. He was a predator who acted with complete impunity.”
You will find the rest on the next page.
